Web Stories Monday, November 16

Forget seconds — New Yorkers may be forced to think twice before filling their Thanksgiving plates with the usual delicious staples this year.

Rising fuel costs, poor harvests due to extreme weather and general inflation are making everything, even the pecans in your grandma’s famous pie, more expensive.

The Post carved into the numbers to find out just how much more New Yorkers will shell out for Thanksgiving dinner this year — and what shoppers can do to keep costs low and flavor high.

Some bites that will cost you more this year — potatoes, pecans, cranberries and the bird itself evgenyb – stock.adobe.com

Even though national prices for Thanksgiving staples were down on average in 2025, the Empire State bucked the overall trend, according to the 2025 Consumer Price Index.

Instead of saving dough while making pie dough, New Yorkers were spending nearly 20% more than fellow Americans, with Turkey Day costing an average of $66.06 per meal.

This year, New Yorkers can expect even higher prices.

The Post spoke with Francisco Martin-Rayo, the co-founder and CEO of agricultural tech company Helios AI, who shared that nearly every table staple will likely eat up your budget.

Some bites that will cost you: potatoes, pecans, cranberries and the big bird itself.

Expect higher prices for this year’s Thanksgiving staples. phpetrunina14 – stock.adobe.com

Last year, the retail price of a frozen whole turkey was $1.03 a pound. This year it’s up about 22.3%, costing folks $1.26 a pound. For a 15-pound turkey, that works out to about $18.90 — or $3.45 more than last year.

The underlying factor? Diesel prices, which Martin-Rayo said are up 70%. When food costs more to transport, that cost carries on to the consumer.

Plus, turkeys must be temperature-controlled during transportation — something that requires even more fuel, and therefore costs even more cash.

Some farmers’ markets may let their shoppers lock in the price of big-ticket items — like your bird. fahrwasser – stock.adobe.com

Also spiking: wholesale potato prices, which are nearly 60% higher than normal, according to price trackers. 

In New York alone, a 70-count Idaho russet potato is selling for $35 per case — about 50% more than last year’s spud haul. That’s no small potatoes, as some Big Apple residents (and restaurants) depend on every dollar. 

Dessert fans may want to brace for a not-so-sweet surprise, too, as pecans on this year’s pie will likely cost more than last year.

Martin-Rayo told The Post that every major pecan state had a bad season due to weather. Georgia’s growers faced exceptionally wet conditions, with rainfall running 68% above even 2018 levels — when Hurricane Michael wiped out the state’s pecan crop.

New Mexico was also hit hard after experiencing its wettest growing season in eight years, leaving little time for farmers to recover with a new crop. 

“With the season ending in December, we don’t think there’s enough of a window for the season to recover, so shoppers should expect both a smaller pecan crop and higher prices,” Martin-Rayo said.

The former avocado trader-turned-entrepreneur also said cranberry prices may rise, as the bog-grown crop suffered insufficient rainfall and wildfire damage this year.

So is Thanksgiving a lost cause this season?

Not at all. Experts say New Yorkers can do three things to ensure full bellies without an empty wallet: Be flexible with this year’s menu, buy your food early and compare prices between stores and farms.

“I would say don’t be so tied to the traditional Thanksgiving meal,” said Martin-Rayo.

“You can do sweet potatoes instead of regular potatoes. Brussels sprouts should have a pretty good year, and so those costs should be lower. Those things really add up,” he said.

New Yorkers are in for a pricier Thanksgiving due to supply chain disruptions and higher diesel costs. Drazen – stock.adobe.com

The businessman also suggested scooping up shelf-stable items like cranberries early, which makes it easier to take advantage of sales and specials.

“Just plan it out a little bit earlier. I think that [shoppers] will be more empowered in terms of how much they’re spending and where they’re spending,” he said.

Lastly, that extra bit of work to compare prices between farmers’ markets and grocery stores may give New Yorkers some serious savings.

“This is where I think planning is really helpful. Go to your local farmers market, go to your local co-op, and go see what the prices are and see what you can order ahead of time,” Martin-Rayo told The Post.

For canned and tinned items, grocery stores have much bigger margins, which means you may be saving more on their shelves. Conversely, some farmers could let shoppers get a better deal on big-ticket items like turkeys, especially if you offer to buy the food in cash.

One last piece of advice from the Harvard grad: Don’t worry so much about the “traditional” food requirements and just enjoy your time together. 

“Thanksgiving is my favorite holiday. It’s just lovely that you all get to get together, and the whole point of it is eating. So you know, as long as you’re doing that, just be flexible with what you’ll serve.”

Read the full article here

Share.

Leave A Reply