New Yorkers may be gearing up for their annual Thanksgiving turkey trot next week, lacing up their sneakers and pinning on numbered bibs for a festive neighborhood 5K.
But on Staten Island, every day is a turkey trot. Hundreds of wild turkeys roam the streets like they own the place, commandeering backyards and bringing traffic to a halt.
Some see them as beloved local celebrities. To others, they’re feathered menaces who have overstayed their welcome.
While the rest of Gotham battles subway rats and pigeons, Staten Islanders have a much bigger bird problem. For decades, wild turkeys have made themselves at home across the borough, even taking flight onto car roofs.
Longtime residents know the drill: Watch your step and prepare for a feathered face-off.
The gobblers strut through busy intersections like they own the runway. Staten Island’s notoriously impatient drivers have little choice but to hit the brakes and wait as the birds cross, sometimes leaving traffic backed up for blocks.
The turkey traffic has sparked some serious road rage. In 2022, footage of a driver lowering his window and shouting “Get the f–k out of here” at a turkey went viral with 5.8 million views on Instagram.
Staten Island resident Stephanie Moyle told The Post that she has seen multiple close call accidents on the road — just from drivers dodging the feathered obstacles.
“They don’t belong in this environment,” Moyle said. “The same thing goes for our deer and fox population — Staten Island doesn’t have the space for wildlife.”
The Staten Island Advance caught up with residents outside Staten Island University Hospital, a known turkey hangout, to hear how they’d deal with the feathered freeloaders.
“You should catch them and take them away upstate,” a local named George said on the video. Another local, Toni Ann, said they are ‘disgusting.’
“I don’t even want to look at them,” she said, even suggesting poisoning the turkeys.
So how did the birds end up ruling the borough in the first place?
Their arrival remains a local urban legend. The most widely accepted account traces their origins to 1999, when a resident reportedly released nine pet turkeys near the South Beach Psychiatric Center in Ocean Breeze.
With no natural predators, those nine original birds multiplied into an army of hundreds.
The fowl are concentrated around Staten Island University Hospital and adjacent neighborhoods like Ocean Breeze, Dongan Hills, and Arrochar. But as they continue to multiply, they’ve expanded their territory to every corner of the borough.
Videos of turkeys chasing residents on their morning commutes and homeowners fending off the birds with baseball bats in their driveways continue to go viral, leaving outsiders both amused and amazed that wild turkeys have made themselves at home in NYC.
Staten Island’s Borough President Vito Fossella told The Post the invasion has been a personal headache since his time in Congress during the early 2000s, when reports of birds hopping onto car hoods and trapping residents in their homes perpetually came through.
“I thought I had a total no-brainer,” Fossella told The Post, recalling his initial plan to relocate the flock to Maryland’s Eastern Shore in the early 2000s. “Then the State Department of Environmental Conservation shut it down because turkeys weren’t indigenous to Maryland. So they stayed (on Staten Island), and the population boomed.”
Decades later, Fossella told The Post he sees no remedy in sight. While longtime residents have learned to live with their feathered neighbors, newcomers are finding out that sharing a backyard with wild turkeys is no walk in the park.
“It’s a mixed bag. Some think they’re neighborhood mascots; others say they’re dirty nuisances and ruining quality of life,” Fossella said.
Fossella said he is open to solutions, but has other wildlife challenges to manage, including the island’s expanding local fox and deer populations. A city deer sterilization program helped reduce the island’s deer count by 15 percent between 2017 and 2019, bringing numbers down from 2,053 to 1,737.
The ongoing battle between Staten Island and its turkey population has even reached the courtroom. In 2019, school administrative aide Carmen Page sued Northwell Health and Staten Island University Hospital, following a turkey encounter near the hospital grounds.
Page claimed that her fear of the aggressive birds caused a fall that resulted in a torn shoulder, four surgeries, and the loss of her job. The jury, however, found the hospital wasn’t liable in a 5-1 decision.
Efforts to control the turkey population have also sparked ethical debates.
In 2013, the U.S. Department of Agriculture, under direction from New York state, began rounding up and euthanizing the birds, then testing their meat to see if it could be donated to food banks and shelters, according to Fast Company NYC. The proposal was ultimately rejected before any turkey made it to the dinner table.
But other efforts to relocate the turkeys have had some success.
In 2018, Councilman Steven Matteo allocated $100,000 in discretionary funds to capture and relocate more birds. The Staten Island Advance reported that more than 150 turkeys were moved to the And-Hof Sanctuary in Catskill between 2014 and 2018, with that number growing to 200 by 2019.
But for residents still sharing their neighborhoods with the birds, city wildlife officials recommend a different approach: coexistence. WildlifeNYC advises against feeding the Eastern wild turkeys and encourages residents to observe them from a safe distance and discourage them from nesting on private property.
Still, some locals welcome their feathered neighbors, including 1987 Miss New York Alice Knisley Matthias, whose yard became a temporary nursery for a mother turkey and her babies.
“I have no problem with them,” Matthias told The Post from her Randall Manor home. “As long as they’re not eating my garden flowers, they’re welcome to pass through.”
Matthias, a lifelong Staten Islander, told The Post she considers the turkeys a tourist attraction, with newcomers wandering through her neighborhood hoping to catch a glimpse. When her sons, now 24 and 20, were younger, she even let them feed the birds in her yard.
The turkeys weren’t exactly winning over everyone on the block, with their squawking sending neighborhood parents into a panic.
“Parents would rush outside thinking our boys were in trouble!” she laughed.
Matthias has no problem rolling out the welcome mat for her feathered neighbors. Last Mother’s Day, she even played midwife when a mother turkey chose her backyard to nest and hatch her eggs.
“When (the turkey) stood up, it was like Mother Ginger in The Nutcracker lifting her skirt — out waddled half a dozen tiny baby turkeys! They slept in our trees, snacked on birdseed, and marched on,” Matthias said, adding that her family occasionally tossed them seeds from their bird feeder.
Still, Matthias marvels at the turkeys’ total takeover of Staten Island’s streets. Even the borough’s most impatient drivers know better than to challenge the feathered road hogs, who can bring traffic to a standstill faster than any speed bump.
“The biggest trucks stop dead in their tracks,” she told The Post. “Ambulances steer around them. Pedestrians complain about drivers, but a turkey steps off the curb and the whole world stops. Honestly, they’re safer crossing the street than kids with crossing guards.”
Standing up to 3 feet tall and capable of sprinting at speeds of up to 25 mph, these birds are no easy neighbors to contend with. Newcomers are often baffled by the feathered residents, frequently turning to social media for advice on how to handle them.
“Do Staten Island turkeys have the right of way, or are they just extremely confident?” Vince Miele posted on the Staten Island Neighbors Facebook page, where long-time residents quickly pointed out that the turkeys are here to stay — and always have the right of way.
One Redditor even asked about hunting his Thanksgiving meal locally, asking on the AskNYC subreddit: “I’ve noticed turkeys roaming around the streets in Staten Island and always wondered if I can hunt one down with a baseball bat. Would I get in trouble for killing a turkey in broad daylight?”
While turkey hunting requires a state license in New York, city regulations prohibit shooting or trapping wildlife within NYC limits, according to NYC.gov. Residents dealing with nuisance birds must hire a licensed Nuisance Wildlife Control Operator through WildlifeNYC.
“We have to just adapt and live with (the turkeys),” Fossella said. “Don’t approach them, they can be vicious. And for people coming for the first time – it’s an eye opener.”
Read the full article here














